When the Yankees left their most dangerous hitter out of the lineup for three straight games, Aaron Boone explained. “Don’t want to put anyone in harm’s way, and especially going into an off day tomorrow,” Boone said, addressing the decision to keep Giancarlo Stanton on the bench. The manager framed it as caution, not panic, and it was a way to safeguard a vital bat in a ballpark with a challenging outfield. To the manager, it was related to being “mindful and careful” with a star he trusts to carry the offense in the stretch run.
However, not everyone was convinced. Former Yankee Clint Frazier went public with his skepticism, highlighting that something more serious was at play. “Giancarlo Stanton missing a third straight game only means one thing … he’s got to be hurt,” Frazier said. Frazier did not stop there, diving into his personal experiences with the Yankees’ approach to injuries. “To be on the bench two nights in a row means something’s going on … they drag out injuries, where they don’t tell you what’s going on. If you’re a superstar, your injury’s getting drug out as long as you want it to.” Frazier’s statement carried the sting of frustration and the credibility of someone who had lived through the team’s notoriously mysterious injury updates.
This was not just idle speculation, either. Aaron Boone said that Stanton had struggled to recover after his stretch of games in right field, saying it was “a little tougher recovering after the last one” and highlighting the larger dimensions of Busch Stadium as part of the manager’s decision. Still, the contrast between his calm reassurance and Frazier’s skepticism established a clash of thought processes — one cautious, the other accusatory.
The outcome? A situation where fans are left to choose which one to believe: Aaron Boone’s steady “day-to-day” framing or Frazier’s blunt insistence that something larger is being hidden. When a veteran publicly challenges the team’s decision, it does not just raise concern related to injuries — it turns the attention on the delicate balance of trust between stars, management, and the fans.
Aaron Boone unveils why he’s keeping Giancarlo Stanton out of the starting lineup for the third game in a row.
Watch #YANKSonYES live on YES and The Gotham Sports App: https://t.co/sWMqNZ0hci pic.twitter.com/1lE6SYKPEC
— YES Network (@YESNetwork) August 17, 2025
While the Stanton situation stirred debate, the Yankees also identified a much-needed spark elsewhere — one that not only lifted the team’s offense in the moment, but also etched a rookie alongside a legendary figure in the team’s history.
Ben Rice steps into Yankees lore with historic RBI feat.
On a night when the Yankees desperately needed a lift, it was Ben Rice who provided a performance for the ages. Driving in seven runs against the Cardinals, the star did not just carry the offense in a 12-8 slugfest — Rice also joined Lou Gehrig in an exclusive team in Yankee history. Before Rice, the only first baseman with multiple seven-RBI games in pinstripes was Gehrig, and the legend achieved the feat nine times. For a young star trying to carve out his place, such a company speaks volumes.
However, what made the night sweeter was the timing. The team has been sliding, struggling to find consistent offense amid injuries and lineup shuffles. Rice’s outburst — a three-run homer to provide the team the guide, a bases-clearing double, and a late RBI single — provided exactly the kind of momentum swing the Yankees had been desperate for. Aaron Judge’s milestone home run took a backseat to Rice’s heroics. In a season full of uncertainty, the star’s emergence not only gave fans a reason to cheer, also injected hope that fresh stars can keep the team afloat while their stars heal and recover.
MLB, Baseball Herren, USA New York Yankees at Los Angeles Angels May 27, 2025, Anaheim, California, USA New York Yankees manager Aaron Boone 17 before the game against the Los Angeles Angels at Angel Stadium. Anaheim Angel Stadium, California, USA, EDITORIAL USE ONLY PUBLICATIONxINxGERxSUIxAUTxONLY Copyright: xGaryxA.xVasquezx 20250527_gav_sv5_003
The team is standing at a vital crossroads, where Boone’s decisions and the locker room’s reaction could define the remainder of the Yankees’ season. Stanton’s role could be in flux; however, the larger issue lies in how the team unites or fractures under pressure.
`
The post Yankees Veteran Turns On Aaron Boone as Manager Announces Tough Giancarlo Stanton Decision appeared first on EssentiallySports.