In baseball, success often feels fleeting, like a perfectly turned double play—here one moment, gone the next. The Baltimore Orioles just gave their fans a masterclass of this uncompromising truth. After a remarkable resurgence, the team surprisingly dismissed Brandon Hyde, the reigning AL Manager of the Year. This move on May 17 has certainly turned heads. It’s left many wondering why they made that choice so abruptly. And this sudden reversal seems to cast a long shadow over the team’s front office.
The news of Hyde’s spread through the league like a wildfire on Saturday. Reason for this abrupt firing? The Orioles cited their disastrous 15-28 start to the 2025 season, placing them firmly at the bottom of the AL East. What’s worse is that they were already 13 games under .500. Their run differential was a jaw-dropping minus 75. Besides Hyde, O’s also decided to part ways with field coordinator Tim Cossins.
As they explore the market for a new manager now, third base coach Tony Mansolino is stepping in as interim manager. And might we say, he has a difficult first task at hand.
The Baltimore Orioles fired manager Brandon Hyde, sources told ESPN.
— Jeff Passan (@JeffPassan) May 17, 2025
Hyde’s tenure with the Baltimore club painted a vivid picture of transformation. He steered the O’s out of a painfully slow rebuild that included seasons of more than 100 losses. He’s the one who guided them to a glorious 101-win season in 2023, resulting in the AL East title. That year, if anyone’s efforts were truly recognized, it was Hyde’s. He was honored with the prestigious AL Manager of the Year award. In the following seasons of 2023 and 2024, the Orioles consecutively clinched a playoff berth under his guidance. He left the club with a record of 421-492.
In an attempt to explain the abrupt decision, Executive Vice President Mike Elias released a statement: “The poor start to our season is ultimately my responsibility. Part of that responsibility is pursuing difficult changes in order to set a different course.” Bidding farewell, Orioles owner David Rubenstein expressed his gratitude, stating. “Brandon Hyde is someone I have come to know and deeply admire. However, as is sometimes the case in baseball, change becomes necessary.”
This high-profile dismissal, despite recent accolades, naturally fueled intense debate and scrutiny. The biggest question cuts through dugout chatter and press box whispers in short order. Was this dismissal a necessary move to jolt a struggling team? Or does the responsibility for the Orioles’ current disaster sit closer to the top—in fact, in the front office itself? The world of baseball is now left to wait and see.
Expert reactions to the Orioles’ decision
Many seasoned baseball voices quickly weighed in on the Orioles’ sudden decision. And they sure didn’t hold back offering their sharp insights into who truly bears responsibility for the team’s current slide.
ESPN’s Buster Olney directly pointed the finger at the front office. He tweeted, “Brandon Hyde is not responsible for the decision to not invest significant resources in pitching, this year, or last year, or the year before that. But here we are.” Olney’s take resonates when you see the team’s 5.31 ERA, ranking 28th in MLB. The starting rotation’s 5.60 ERA is equally troubling. These numbers suggest a clear failure to bolster the pitching staff, a task for the front office, not the manager.
Echoing this sentiment, Travis Sawchik of The Athletic suggested Hyde was far from the main issue. He stated, “Brandon Hyde was down the list of issues in BAL. I think about everyone first guessed the lack of SP investment this past winter.” Indeed, many questioned the Orioles’ offseason strategy. They lost their ace, Corbin Burnes, and brought in aging veterans like Tomoyuki Sugano and Charlie Morton. These moves did little to inspire confidence. The team’s subsequent struggles, particularly the starting pitching’s 6.04 ERA in April, proved those early doubts correct.
Former MLB catcher Chris Gimenez also offered a blunter take on the situation. He implied Hyde was made the necessary fall guy. Gimenez said, “I can’t say it’s Brandon Hyde’s fault, but somebody had to fall on the sword.” This “fall on the sword” narrative is common in baseball when things go south. We saw it earlier this season with Pittsburgh’s Derek Shelton fired on May 8 and Colorado’s Bud Black dismissed on May 11. Despite Hyde’s recent Manager of the Year award, his firing fits this unfortunate pattern for skippers.
Analyst Arving Gonzalez also felt the O’s manager was unfairly targeted. He expressed, “Hyde deserved better, he didn’t built that pitching staff, but that’s how it works, unfairly.” Gonzalez’s point hits home when recalling Hyde’s achievements. He transformed a rebuilding Orioles team into a 101-win division champion in 2023. Yet, the current team’s pitching woes, evidenced by that league-worst 5.31 ERA, reflect roster construction failures by the front office. The manager, unfortunately, paid the price for these deficiencies.
Finally, former catcher and FOX Sports Analyst A.J. Pierzynski questioned the firing’s ultimate impact. He mused, “Does firing him change anything? It’s the same people; it’s the same position players.” Pierzynski’s skepticism is understandable. A new manager inherits the same roster, including a pitching staff struggling significantly. With a 15-28 record and a -75 run differential, the Orioles’ problems appear deeper than just coaching. Unless the player personnel or front office philosophy changes, a new manager faces the same uphill battle.
The post Orioles Front Office Under Heavy Scrutiny for Firing Their AL Manager of the Year appeared first on EssentiallySports.