Dylan Cease is off to a strong start in his first season with the Padres, quickly establishing himself as a reliable presence in the rotation. Armed with his signature high-velocity fastball and sharp-breaking slider, the right-hander has shown flashes of the dominance that once made him a Cy Young finalist. On the mound, he’s been composed and commanding, key ingredients for a Padres team aiming to turn potential into postseason contention.
But while Cease’s performance has drawn praise, his life off the field has recently drawn attention. Amid his professional resurgence, headlines have begun to shift focus to his personal affairs, pulling him into a different kind of spotlight, one that could test the balance between athlete and individual. One that is unique in its true sense.
Well, you know Chris Paddack, former Padres pitcher currently with the Twins, got tangled here with Cease’s love life. How?
Current Padre Dylan Cease is now dating Former Padre Chris Paddack’s Ex GF
He also just had the best outing of his season yesterday
Is GigaChad Cease going to start balling?!? pic.twitter.com/Jycr3eLkN7
— Devine Sports Gospel (@DevineGospel) May 9, 2025
According to reports, Cease is now dating the former girlfriend of Chris Paddack. The connection has sparked whispers both inside and outside the baseball world, not just for its angle, but for the shadow it casts over old clubhouse ties and the close-knit nature of the baseball community.
While not much is known till now, it is confirmed by Devine Sports Gospel. Well, there is nothing wrong on the side of Cease or Paddack. Well, the fans are not all on the same page, acknowledging this statement. However, we hope that Cease and Paddack are still on good terms and there is no bad blood between them. You would also agree that it is not obvious to be in a relationship by checking the MLB status.
But the history of Paddack with the Padres is what makes the fans wonder about the behind-the-scenes story. Paddack left the Padres in 2023 amid some highs and lows.
Remember when Paddack commented on the Padres jersey? He jokingly referred to the Padres’ brown and gold uniforms as resembling a UPS delivery outfit, stoking a controversy back in 2022. In contrast, Cease was anticipated to be a cornerstone of the Padres’ rotation. As of early May, he holds a 1–2 record with a 4.91 ERA over eight starts, accumulating 48 strikeouts and a 1.41 WHIP.
So, both are settled in different teams, but now they have reconnected with a girl as the fine line.
Mixed-bag fan reactions about Cease’s relationship
A few fans are yet to accept the twist of the tale here, even considering that it is not related to Cease’s on-field antics.
Dating another players ex is not a chad move
— Cliff Yablonski (@CliffYablo75488) May 9, 2025
So, dating another player’s ex is not a chad move? Well, the baseball community works differently. Dating another player’s ex in a close-knit league like MLB can create drama, tension in the clubhouse, or even impact team chemistry. It’s not exactly a Chad move in the traditional sense of confident. Instead, it often comes off as disrespectful or messy, especially given the small world of professional sports where reputations travel fast. Maybe now the heat will come from the Twins fans. Typical MLB fan war!
“She traded up. So did the Pads.” Ahh, pure sarcasm is the reason why MLB feels engaging even beyond the on-field activities. Now this fan is referring to how Paddack got traded to the Twins in 2023, similar to his former girlfriend. She also traded herself from Paddack to Cease! Hilarious and spontaneous point by this fan. Well, for those unaware, trade speculation with Dylan Cease is getting higher. He’s in the final year of his contract and is expected to test free agency after the season. The Padres, facing payroll constraints and roster needs, have reportedly received interest from a few suitors. Once that happens, what will be his relationship status then?
Ahh, Paddack was not bad when he was with the Padres. Yes, you can call it a rollercoaster ride, but calling him sucks, might be a amplification. “No because paddack sucks,” one fan remarked. After a standout rookie season in 2019, where he posted a 3.33 ERA and earned the nickname Paddack Attack for his aggressive pitching style, expectations were high. However, subsequent seasons saw a decline in performance, with issues such as a less effective fastball and lack of a reliable third pitch contributing to his struggles. Injuries further hampered his progress, including a right elbow inflammation that ended his 2021 season early. So yes, he didn’t sucked as such.
Is there a list of approved girls for Padres players to date or something? This is odd. https://t.co/YRdtrzr5H6
— MSS (@MySoxSummer) May 9, 2025
It is always a treat to watch how MLB fans come up with unique arguments. While we don’t know if there is any list given to the Padres players, Cease is not the first to get into a relationship with a former player’s ex. Alex Rodriguez reportedly dated Mientkiewicz’s ex-girlfriend while they were teammates in 2007. The situation never exploded publicly, but it was mentioned in gossip circles and added to A-Rod’s long list of tabloid storylines. Hence, we cannot conclude Dylan Cease’s case as odd.
“She upgraded.” Really? So far in 2025, Cease has outperformed Paddack, and the numbers back it up. Both pitchers have struggled to some degree, which is evident in their ERAs (4.91 – 5.57). Moreover, Cease’s 27.0% strikeout rate nearly doubles Paddack’s 16.6%. So, while both have room to grow, Cease has shown flashes of front-line potential, whereas Paddack’s 2025 campaign points more toward inconsistency and vulnerability. The fan might be right here if we compare based on the on-field stats. Still, it’s a little odd to compare personal space with on-field figures.
There is nothing negative to comment on about Dylan Cease’s relationship. Hopefully, they will lead a happy life, and both Cease and Paddack will offer a few good performances on the field.
The post Dylan Cease’s Relationship With Former Padres Player’s Ex Sparks Heated Debate Among Fans: “Not a Chad Move” appeared first on EssentiallySports.