The Toronto Blue Jays might have sealed the historic deal for their clubhouse. However, the possibility of losing another crucial player from their offensive engine clearly sounds alarming. But do they have a solution? Turns out, yes. And it’s already making headlines due to the potential contract he might receive. So, the Blue Jays’ loyal fans can sit back and relax as this shortstop could be the next big thing in line.
Still developing his abilities in the minor leagues , this prospect is creating a degree of enthusiasm hardly seen since Guerrero Jr.’s entrance and the previously stated possible free agent. Whispers across the baseball world point to a unique combination of offensive firepower and defensive skills for this rising star. He’s not just expected to make a smooth transition, but also sustain high-level performance at the Rogers Centre infield for years to come. So, who’s this young star?
The birds of the North have a 19-year-old shortstop, Arjun Nimmala, who has caught the eye as the next top prospect. Drafted 20th overall in 2023, Nimmala has stood out with his play at High-A Vancouver, hitting .280 with seven home runs and 15 RBIs in only 29 games. His quick rise from No. 78 to No. 59 on MLB Pipeline’s Top 100 highlights his ability. Looks like the Blue Jays’ future is indeed bright.
As Sportsnet baseball columnist, Shi Davidi, correctly pointed out, “You’re definately looking at the highest upside prospect the Blue Jays probably had since Guerrero & Bichette came through the system.” This feeling shows the team’s faith in Nimmala’s capacity to significantly impact at the major league level. “The Blue Jays have to get this guy right. They haven’t had this type of sealing in a prospect in a while. He has a chance to be a really dynamic player. So, I expect them to let him force their hands. But, you know, one thing about him is that he wants the challenge. He definately relish being against older competition, tougher competition.”
Perhaps the front office is taking steps to enhance his performance.
“With [Arjun Nimmala], you’re looking at the highest upside prospect the Blue Jays have had since Guerrero & Bichette came through the system.”@ShiDavidi outlines the #BlueJays’ plan for the 19-year-old shortstop with @SNJeffBlair & Kevin Barker.#LightsUpLetsGo pic.twitter.com/QUzEHibKLs
— Sportsnet 590 The FAN (@FAN590) May 12, 2025
The Blue Jays’ coaching staff has closely monitored Nimmala’s growth. Initial difficulties in the Florida State League were followed by swing technique changes that improved performance, especially against pitches in the strike zone. However, his maturity and flexibility at such a young age, his future development seems promising. But who can he replace? Bo Bichett!
This loss of power—a fundamental element of Bichette’s offensive profile—is particularly worrying. Bichette is a great player to have on the roster, and even Jeff Passan agrees. Just a few days ago, Passan said, “The ability at Bo Bichette’s size to take the ball to the opposite field, over the fence, is a very rare quality for a shortstop… He had it, and that part seems to have more or less disappeared.” He may be approaching free agency and the draw of a rich, $200 million-plus contract from rival clubs.
For the Blue Jays, the contrast between Bichette’s current difficulties and Nimmala’s rising path offers an interesting story. The team surely appreciates Bichette’s previous efforts and his ability to recover his offensive form. But after signing Vladdy for $500M, they also must consider the future.
Though Bichette’s recent trade talk is troubling, Nimmala’s rise offers a possible fix. If the Blue Jays decide to let Bichette go, they can be confident that a capable replacement is ready to step in. This situation mirrors the team’s previous changes, such as the successful integration of Guerrero Jr. into the lineup. However, it looks like they need to make a decision quickly, as clubs are already lining up for Bichette.
From Toronto to Detroit?
With a 20-21 record, the Blue Jays are in a difficult situation as the 2025 MLB season moves on. The AL East is quite competitive, so the team’s performance in the following weeks will decide its future. And what’s that? Whether they become buyers or sellers at the trade deadline. All-Star shortstop Bichette is one athlete attracting great notice especially given his steady play. This season, Bichette is hitting .286 with three home runs, 21 RBIs, and an OPS of .748.
A recent trade suggestion from FanSided indicates the Blue Jays might send Bichette to the Detroit Tigers, who are leading the AL Central and trying to improve their infield after relocating Javy Baez to center field. Toronto would get left-handed reliever Tyler Holton and shortstop Trey Sweeney in return. Hitting .267 with four home runs, 18 RBIs, and an OPS of.735, Sweeney has shown promise. With a WHIP of 1.16 and 19 strikeouts across 19 innings, Holton has been successful out of the bullpen, recording a 3.32 ERA.
“The Tigers weren’t able to get Bregman. They can’t miss again if they get the opportunity,” wrote Wynston Wilcox. “Bichette isn’t necessarily the best option, but he could be worth it. Unfortunately, it’s not up to Detroit. It’s up to Toronto to decide if they’re ready to move on from Bichette.”
The Blue Jays’ success will be critical in deciding their course of action as the trade deadline draws near. Should they choose to trade Bichette, the suggested transaction with the Tigers offers a fair exchange that might help both clubs, depending on their objectives for the rest of the season.
The post Best Player Since Vladimir Guerrero Jr. to Step Up as Blue Jays Risk Losing Star to $200M Market Lure appeared first on EssentiallySports.