Justin Thomas made a remarkable showing at the 2025 RBC Heritage, reminding the golf community why his name is still respected. His thrilling performance at Harbor Town sparked discussions about his legacy in American golf history while also ending a discouraging losing streak. Known for his fiery personality and aggressive shooting, Thomas received considerable praise during the event for his bold shot selection and composure under pressure.
With his victory, he also managed to secure sixth place for Team USA at the next Ryder Cup with enough points—an additional accomplishment in a career already full of honors. With that momentum, J.T. is being discussed in terms of legacy rather than merely a comeback.
Meanwhile, Scottie Scheffler, the world No. 1, is on a tear! With a second major at the 2024 Masters, three straight PGA Tour Player of the Year titles (2022–2024), a 2024 Olympic gold, and multiple Players Championship wins, it’s all grace on this side. But recently, Justin Thomas’ legacy was highlighted when Golf Today’s Eamon Lynch and Damon Hack sparked an intense debate on the golfer’s generational brilliance. Let’s check out what unfolded!
Justin Thomas’ place among American Golfers
For a general summary of who’s had this elite spot, Rory McIlroy, a major champion himself, has called Tiger Woods’ 10-year reign in the late ’90s and 2000s “the best we have ever seen by anyone,” praising Woods for his unmatched skill and consistency during that era. Even Scottie Scheffler has received praises from the recent Masters winner, who thinks “his (Scheffler’s) consistency, his attitude… he’s amazing to watch the way he manages himself around the golf course.” But for Damon Hack, it’s someone else.
In X (formerly Twitter), a video clip was posted by Golf Today with the title, “I would make an argument he’s actually the best American player of his generation.” Eamon Lynch and Damon Hack dug into JT’s resume and didn’t mince words. Going a step further, Hack declared Thomas the best American player of his generation. He emphasized Thomas’s 16 victories on the PGA Tour and a consistent elite-level presence.
“I would make an argument he’s actually the best American player of his generation.”@eamonlynch and @damonhackGC react to Justin Thomas’ career resume. pic.twitter.com/kFlH8MpF6U
— Golf Today (@GCGolfToday) April 21, 2025
Lynch supported the thought, noting that Justin Thomas’ career trajectory remains among the most remarkable in contemporary American golf, despite occasional setbacks. In the Scottie Scheffler age of domination, it’s simple to ignore his resume, but the numbers speak for themselves. His leadership position in the locker room for Team USA has further solidified his reputation, and his two significant victories, the 2017 and 2022 PGA Championships, serve as benchmarks.
Even though Scheffler has recently achieved incredible heights in his game, Hack stressed the significance of understanding a golfer’s career history. Hack stated, “Scheffler may well pass him in short order, but if you’re looking at that sort of famous class of 2011 that merged onto the PGA Tour, I don’t see anybody who’s really doing what Justin Thomas has.” JT’s argument is more than just a hot take; it’s a legitimate one, supported by a well-designed resume due to his statistics, durability, and sheer tenacity. While accolades and legacy conversations swirl, it’s JT’s revitalized short game that’s quietly fueling his climb back to the top. Let’s dig deeper into this as well!
With career-best putting, Thomas eyes major contention
Justin Thomas’s outstanding putting performance is partly responsible for his recent success. In May 2023, Justin Thomas teamed up with AimPoint Golf and coach John Graham to master the AimPoint system, which uses tactile feedback from his feet and visual cues to read greens. This method has sharpened his green-reading, boosted his confidence, and eliminated guesswork on the course.
He made five putts over 20 feet at the RBC Heritage, including the game-winning birdie, using a prototype Scotty Cameron putter to great effect. For Thomas, this noticeable improvement on the greens has changed the game. Thomas has fine-tuned his setup to reduce putterface rotation, keeping his eyes directly over the ball and hands under his shoulders. This helps him strike the ball more consistently, sending it on the intended line.
However, he understands that improving his driving distance and accuracy is necessary to be a reliable contender in big tournaments. Even though his putting has improved significantly, he has occasionally struggled in high-stakes competitions due to inconsistent off-tee play. Resolving these problems might be the secret to achieving even more success on the biggest stages in golf.
With his driving game back on track and his putting game at its best, Thomas is ready to make a big impression in the next majors. His latest triumph not only snapped a protracted losing trend, but it suggested that one of the best golfers in America might be ready to regain his former glory.
The post Ignoring Scottie Scheffler, Eamon Lynch Asserts Justin Thomas as ‘Best American Player’ appeared first on EssentiallySports.